When Painters Lit the Night: Eight Paintings from Gaslight to the All-Night Diner

Alexey Bogolyubov’s view across the Moskva River towards the illuminated Kremlin in 1883

A lamp is among the smallest things in a night painting. Its reflection can fill half a river. Between Grimshaw’s Leeds of 1881 and Hopper’s New York of 1942, painters found uses for artificial light that its inventors could hardly have anticipated. A shop window could describe the shape of a street. A paper lantern could make the distance to the moon suddenly uncertain.

These eight paintings are arranged in pairs. Each begins from a position that someone looking at the scene might actually occupy, whether aboard a boat, at an upstairs window or on the pavement outside a diner.

Monuments from the river

A pale beam cuts across the sky above the illuminated Kremlin and the dark Moskva River.
Kremlin Illumination in 1883
Alexey Bogolyubov, 1883
The tower rises beyond boats on the Seine, with a balloon in the pale evening sky.
The Eiffel Tower at Night
Alexey Bogolyubov, 1889

From the opposite bank of the Moskva, a spectator at Alexander III’s coronation in 1883 could take in the Kremlin at a glance. Bogolyubov gives us that distant station. Green and gold lights follow the fortifications, turning a great mass of masonry into a drawing against the sky. The pale beam entering from the right does something stranger. For a moment the air itself has an edge.

The boats in the foreground explain part of the picture’s appeal. Down at their level, each ripple breaks the illuminated wall into pieces. A display devised to give the imperial city a single, legible outline has a second existence on the water, where wind and current can rearrange it. The city’s electric illuminations extended to Red Square and the Great Stone Bridge. Bogolyubov’s choice of the river gives him a view of the festivities that a spectator in the square could scarcely have had.

Six years later he used an upright canvas for the Eiffel Tower, newly opened for the Paris Universal Exhibition. Gas burners traced its ironwork and platforms, and electric projectors operated at the summit. Yet the most delicate part of the painting is the tower’s upper reach, where the iron narrows against a sky still pale enough to hold a balloon. Below, smoke from a vessel drifts across the river. The difference between smoke dispersing and iron holding its shape makes the tower’s slenderness palpable. Both paintings record public spectacles. Paris also preserves the passing hour.

The street after rain

Light from shopfronts falls across the wet street between dark buildings in Leeds.
Boar Lane, Leeds by Lamplight
John Atkinson Grimshaw, 1881
White street lamps and warmer shop lights recede along a wet Paris boulevard seen from above.
The Boulevard Montmartre at Night
Camille Pissarro, 1897

On Boar Lane the light a shopkeeper has paid for reaches a good deal farther than the shop door. The windows run along one side of Grimshaw’s Leeds street. Their brightness returns in the road below, interrupted by the uneven surface and the passage of traffic. Look at the upper storeys and much of that colour disappears. Commerce has given the street a luminous ground floor.

Grimshaw knew his home city well and painted several versions of Boar Lane. By 1881 it was already a remodelled thoroughfare. Its south side had been rebuilt after the road was widened. In the painting, the long perspective allows one shopfront to succeed another almost to the vanishing point. The damp roadway gathers those separate premises into a continuous view. It is possible to follow the route a pedestrian would take simply by following the light.

Pissarro looked down onto the Boulevard Montmartre from a hotel window in 1897. Of fourteen views he painted of the boulevard that year, this is the night scene. The high viewpoint lets him distinguish three forms of illumination within a few inches of canvas. Cool electric arc lamps mark the roadway. Gas burns more warmly in the shops. The oil lamps of waiting cabs make smaller, mobile points. Rain repeats the differences on the pavement. Seen close up, a dab of paint might be a lamp or its reflection. From a few steps back the dabs sort themselves into the stationary lights of a street and the vehicles moving through it.

Two September nights in Arles

Yellow café awning and empty chairs beside a cobbled street under a blue, starry sky.
Café Terrace at Night
Vincent van Gogh, 1888
Gold reflections stretch down a blue river beneath stars, with two figures on the near bank.
Starry Night Over the Rhône
Vincent van Gogh, 1888

In September 1888 Van Gogh set up outdoors on the Place du Forum to paint a café terrace by gaslight. The lamp gives him an entire corner of the square in yellow. The awning catches it overhead, chair backs pick it up below, and the cobbles carry it past the last table. Across the street, a narrow passage of blue leads into the distance. Cover the patch of starry sky at the top and the terrace still reads as an evening scene. The blue has already entered the street.

Later that month he painted the Rhône. Here a town’s worth of gaslight occupies a thin strip on the far bank. Almost all the room that the lamps require lies beneath them. Their reflections descend in long, broken bands of orange and yellow, while the stars above occupy comparatively little space. It is worth lingering over that reversal of scale. An immense star can be set down with a few touches of paint. A modest riverside lamp needs a considerable length of canvas to convey what it does to moving water.

Two figures on the near shore give the Rhône a point from which to measure distance. At the café an empty chair offers a different measure, the short distance from the street to a seat at a table. These are companion studies in colour by a painter working in one town within a few weeks. Each nevertheless asks the viewer to stand somewhere quite particular.

Figures within reach

Figures in white costumes lift golden lanterns among branches above stone steps.
The Lantern Bearers
Maxfield Parrish, 1908
Three customers and a counterman inside a brightly lit corner diner facing a dark, empty street.
Nighthawks
Edward Hopper, 1942

The straight edges of the steps in Parrish’s The Lantern Bearers give the performers firm ground for an awkward task. Knees bend beneath loose white costumes, arms reach up and hands find places among the branches. The golden discs are so evenly shaped that the small adjustments of weight below them can be easy to miss. Follow one lantern down to the person responsible for it and the decorative pattern becomes an account of physical work.

Parrish made the painting for reproduction in Collier’s. The yellow globes against deep blue would carry across a printed page, while the original’s layers of pigment and varnish reward a closer look. Crystal Bridges points out that six lanterns can be traced to the performers. Four other spheres are harder to locate. Where a hand stops giving us a sense of size, a circle of yellow might belong to the garden or to the sky beyond it.

Hopper’s Nighthawks brings us just as close to its figures. Across a deserted pavement, the diner’s curved window offers a view of three customers and the man behind the counter. Fluorescent lighting was still relatively new in 1942. Here its steady spill picks out the kerb outside as clearly as the counter within. A glass wall almost vanishes under that illumination, yet Hopper gives the spectator no visible entrance. We can make out a customer’s hand and still have no idea what anyone is saying.

Across these eight paintings, the strongest clue to the character of a light often lies at its farthest reach. On Boar Lane it is the last glimmer from a shop caught in the wet road. In Arles it is a broken bar of gold on the Rhône. In Nighthawks it is the patch of pavement outside the glass, bright enough for someone to stand and look in.

Sources and further reading